Farewell To Threads, And What Comes Next

Posted on by Scott

I deleted my Threads account today. Meta’s previous announcements about the end of third-party fact-checking and changes to moderation rules (to enable more abuse of people from marginalized communities on its platforms) and Mastodon CEO Eugen Rochko speaking out regarding the danger of the changes prompted me to turn off the fediverse-sharing feature on my Threads account. At the time, I was unsure if I would continue to have a Threads account.

Meta’s announcement today that they’re immediately terminating DEI programs inside the company gave me the push I needed to delete my account from an app that frankly isn’t that good. The tech industry I’ve worked in since before Facebook ever existed didn’t treat people who weren’t white and male very well for decades before that. DEI efforts across the tech industry were largely belated, token efforts at most companies, that didn’t meaningfully increase the diversity of rank-and-file employees or leadership. Meta retreating from DEI feels like yet another slap at black folks who have already endured far more than enough between the death of affirmative action in higher education, a legal settlement that literally prevents black people from giving away their own money to black women the rest of the venture capital industry ignores, the outcome of the presidential election, and everything else that comes along with what we should have left behind from Trump’s first term. I don’t even want to imagine how awful it must have been for Meta’s now-former chief diversity officer, Maxine Williams, to see Mark Zuckerberg casually nuke a decade of her work.

What’s next (as detailed in an earlier post) is more financial support for decentralized social media and efforts to create more hospitable online spaces for black folks (like Blacksky) and other marginalized communities that Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, (and others) have targeted for abuse. My Mastodon server (hachyderm.io) administrators opted to defederate from Threads in the interest of protecting their users who are part of marginalized communities. I expect many other Mastodon instances of varying sizes to follow suit, or apply some moderation to Threads accounts. Deleting other Meta accounts (Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp) is much harder than deleting Threads because of how many meaningful relationships I have with people that social media makes it easier to maintain. Perhaps this will be a year of seriously seeking alternatives–and making more efforts to connect in real life.

Charitable Giving in 2024 (Part 2)

Posted on by Scott

This will wrap up my annual charitable giving post that I began on Christmas Eve with a Part 1.

Other Charitable Giving (continued)

Additional charitable giving recipients not listed previously include the following:

Other Giving

In addition to giving for charitable purpose that are tax-deductible, I’ll highlight a few tip jars, Patreon memberships, and other avenues I’ve taken to support people and causes that I find worthwhile.

  • The Contraband Wagon
    I initially met him through Twitter, and he’s taken on the exceedingly difficult challenge of creating constructive conversations on the issue of race. I had the honor of being a panelist for one of the live conversations he moderated on the issue of race in the tech industry. You can find clips of his conversations on YouTube and join his Patreon to get the full-length conversations.
  • Mastodon
    I began supporting the Mastodon project through Patreon in November 2022 after Elon Musk took over Twitter. As we’ve watched Musk turn Twitter into a propaganda and disinformation platform to (unfortunately successfully) elect Donald Trump, those of us with the means putting money behind efforts to help decentralized social media networks succeed will only grow more important. They recently began selling merchandise which also helps support their operations, which gave me an excuse to buy a stuffed version of their mascot.
  • Hachyderm
    Hachyderm.io is the Mastodon server I moved to in 2023 after initially joining the much larger mastodon.cloud. I began sponsoring them this year with a small monthly contribution via GitHub.
  • emptywheel
    The blog of independent journalist Marcy Wheeler, she’s effectively become the ombudsman of The New York Times, The Washington Post, and other mainstream media outlets. She doesn’t just call out shortcomings and failings in their coverage, she clarifies issues that might otherwise be confusing. She’s one of just two journalists I value enough to support directly.
  • Blacksky
    Created and maintained by Rudy Fraser, it is effectively its own social media network for black folks on Bluesky that leverages the AT Protocol. I began contributing to his work this month via Open Source Collective, a fiscal host for numerous open source projects I used back when I was still writing software full time including webpack, vue, ESLint, and thousands of others.

Giving Plans for 2025

I don’t anticipate any changes in my financial giving plans next year beyond possibly giving a bit more to charities I already donate to, and to my church. Once I’ve completed a leadership training program I’m currently taking (in June 2025), I will look for an opportunity to regularly donate my time and expertise to a cause that needs them.

Charitable Giving in 2024 (Part 1)

Posted on by Scott

My final post of last year talked about charitable giving, but this I’m starting a bit earlier. This annual post is as much of a self-reminder to donate to worthy causes as it is to encourage those who read them to do the same.

Religiously-Motivated Charitable Giving

In addition to donating to my home church and my high school alma mater, I gave a bit to the Adventist Community Services of Greater Washington. If you’re in the DC/Metro area and are looking for a cause that helps families in need, consider them as a recipient for your year-end giving.

Other Charitable Giving

Last year’s merger between CIR/Reveal and Mother Jones didn’t change how they accepted donations. Researching this post gave me the opportunity to restart monthly donations to them which had lapsed. 2024 turned out to be a year of mainstream media taking a step backward in quality and/or being acquired by right-wing ideologues. January brought the purchase of The Baltimore Sun by the owner of Sinclair Broadcasting. So the advice I gave last year to find and consider supporting a local non-profit newsroom was advice I had to follow quite quickly myself. The Baltimore Banner covers what happens at Maryland’s state capitol quite well. It’s now my only written local news source since I dropped my Washington Post subscription after they got scooped on Justice Alito’s insurrectionist flag-flying despite having a multi-year head start.

HBO/Max opted to cancel their deal with Sesame Workshop for new episodes so they’re seeking a new partner. Since then, Sesame Workshop has become very active online seeking donations, and I responded. Sesame Street was a substantial part of the TV programming I consumed as a kid (because it was on PBS), and my children have too.

Another new recipient of charitable giving this year was the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture. I visited in-person during the week of Thanksgiving to see the Code Switch exhibit before it closed, and bought a bunch of books in their bookstore before I left (all purchase proceeds support the center itself). You can also give directly to the New York Public Library system.

Other charitable giving recipients so far this year included the following (in no particular order):

A follow-up post after Christmas will cover the rest of my charitable giving for the year and plans for 2025.

The Return of White Impunity for Black Death

Posted on by Scott

Merriam-Webster defines impunity as exemption or freedom from punishment, harm, or loss. With their acquittal of Daniel Penny on the charge of criminally-negligent homicide in his killing of Jordan Neely, impunity is what the jury granted him. Jordan Neely was lynched for having a mental health crisis while black, poor, and homeless. A jury of Daniel Penny’s peers showed him the mercy that he didn’t show Jordan Neely. It didn’t matter that that Penny’s Marine instructor testified that he executed the hold incorrectly. It didn’t matter that at least one passenger is on video warning Penny that his chokehold was going to kill Neely. It didn’t matter that Neely had no weapon and didn’t harm anyone on the train before Penny literally choked the life out of him. The video of Neely being asphyxiated is a modern-day lynching postcard now.

I’m old enough to remember watching video footage of Rodney King being beaten within an inch of his life on video. I remember watching broadcasts of the destruction that resulted from people enraged by the verdict (and some opportunists too). Fast-forward almost 30 years and one of Ahmaud Arbery’s lynchers leaked the video of his crime thinking it would help him. He and his co-conspirators will likely spend the rest of their natural lives in prison. Video of George Floyd’s excruciating death under the knee of Derek Chauvin will keep the man in prison for nearly 2 decades from now. But just 4 year later, a vigilante can strangle a man to death with impunity.

My cynical mind wonders how the jurors who acquitted Daniel Penny responded to the broad daylight murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. Perhaps the response to his murder (which has included very dark jokes and applause on social media) and the response to Neely’s lynching are two sides of the same coin.

Either way, we are (and have been for far too long) a nation too comfortable with violence, too numb to the suffering of those who are most often its victims. This puts everyone in a marginalized community at greater risk—not just from police (who will operate with even greater impunity than they already had once the second Trump administration begins), but now apparently from white vigilantes also.

A Nation Without Mercy, Revisited

Posted on by Scott

Yesterday, a mutual on Bluesky shared this news:

How can you be deadlocked when HIS HAIR PROBABLY SPEAKS AFRIKAANS BY ITSELF?!!

[image or embed]

— Ash Higgins (@ashhiggins.bsky.social) December 6, 2024 at 3:48 PM

It reminded me a post I wrote last year about just how broken this allegedly Christian nation’s understanding of the parable of the good Samaritan is. “He had to die, just in case” may yet spare Daniel Penny up to 15 years in prison that a manslaughter conviction could yield as a sentence. Like the trial of those who lynched Ahmaud Arbery, the only reason there was a trial at all was some public outcry that Penny was initially released without charges after he was first questioned by police. While Penny is also charged with criminally negligent homicide, the maximum sentence for a conviction on that charge is just 4 years. It’s also possible (if not probably) that the jury will will show Penny the mercy he lacked for Jordan Neely and find him not guilty–despite video evidence of him slowly but surely squeezing that man’s life out of him.

In the time since I first wrote A Nation Without Mercy, the “active and ongoing dehumanization and criminalization of the poor and mentally-ill” has continued. The conservative majority on the Supreme Court ruled that cities can ban people from sleeping and camping in public–even if the cities offer no alternative shelter. In a country where homelessness is rising, a housing shortage persists, and Trump is returning to the White House with a government unified under GOP control, the likelihood of homeless people ending up with fines, criminal records, and even prison terms seems uncomfortably high.

We Are Going Back

Posted on by Scott

I hated the “zombie Palpatine” storyline for awhile on social media, but the United States of America willingly chose to reenact this in real-life by reelecting Donald Trump. But in a result even worse than 2016, he won the popular vote–a feat he failed to achieve in two previous runs for the White House. Votes are still being counted as I write this, so we don’t have a full picture of the final outcome, but it seems likely that the GOP will control all three branches of the federal government again. Trump appears to not have grown his vote totals from 2020 much at all–but some 11 million fewer people voted for Kamala Harris this cycle than voted for Joe Biden four years ago. To the extent there is any silver lining in this election wipeout, my home state is sending its first black senator to Washington, along with keeping my House representative Jamie Raskin in his seat.

Every post-mortem of Kamala Harris’ loss that I’ve read sucks–except Michael Harriot’s. It seems that black people in this country are nearly alone in believing in the dream of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr for racial equality in this country–and that is why we are going back. The only question which remains to be answered is “how far back?” The Trump rally in Madison Square Garden before the the election suggests a return to the 1930s, when the pro-Nazi German-American Bund met openly and freely in New York, New Jersey, and elsewhere before World War II began. Trump (and JD Vance’s) blood libel of law-abiding Haitian migrants in Ohio and elsewhere and their campaigning on mass deportation and border camps sets this country’s return destination to the 1950s, and Operation Wetback–the largest mass deportation in this country’s history. We can be certain that the same administration which birthed the child separation policy at our southern border–a policy that years later has left hundreds of children growing up with strangers, separated from their real parents–will devise a sequel to Operation Wetback which makes the original look humane by comparison. The end of birthright citizenship–another part of Trump’s xenophobic plans–along with the return of the Muslim ban of his first term intimates a return to an 1860s United States after the Civil War but before the ratification of the 14th Amendment. This is just a small sample of the threats which await in the future. We don’t know if the Affordable Care Act will survive. We don’t know if the Department of Education will survive–along with the oversight and mandates it provides which ensure that my son gets support in public school for his special needs. We don’t know what will become of the FDA, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, or any other federal agency responsible for protecting Americans from threats to their physical or financial health.

From January 20, 2025 onward, things will change. The coming days, weeks, and months will bring negative impacts that Trump’s non-wealthy supporters did not anticipate. Tariffs are certainly returning, along with the inflation that comes from companies increasing their prices to maintain their profit margins. I’m good on the appliances front myself, but I might be upgrading more of my personal technology earlier than I planned to avoid the price increases that tariffs will bring. The mass deportation plans, possible Affordable Care Act repeal, and other aspects of Project 2025 may create infighting, backlash, and enough pain nationwide to create a small window to mitigate some of the damage in 2026–if elections remain a thing we still have in this country. That hope may be a dangerous thing, but I will nurture it nonetheless.

Despite these future threats, I have decided to focus more on the present. What can I do today to make sure I’m ok, that my wife and kids are ok, and that the people who matter to me are ok? Answering those questions and doing as many of those things as possible, and repeating that cycle the day after that is what I can do. In addition, I can figure out what I can do beyond voting to make the spaces I inhabit and have influence in a little better. It may not be much, but it feels like a more productive and sustainable alternative than despair.

My First YouTube Video

Posted on by Scott
A hastily-made tutorial for sharing your screen and sound in Zoom by yours truly

I made the tutorial you see above entirely with the following tools:

  • QuickTime Player
  • iMovie
  • Zoom

The reason I made it was a recent struggle one of the presenters of our weekly Zoom Bible study had to get their sound shared along with their screen for the music and videos that were part of the presentation.

As long as I’ve owned Macs, it wasn’t until trying to figure out how to capture what I was doing in Zoom that I learned the QuickTime Player also has a screen recording feature. So with that new (to me) information, I wrote myself a little script and followed it to record my demo.

Once I captured the demo (and the Zoom recording of the brief solo meeting I used to demonstrate screen and sound sharing), then it was time to combine them into a single video. This is where iMovie comes in.

First I pulled in the two clips and trimmed them to the desired places. Next I threw in a cross-dissolve between them. I also tried adding a voiceover to clarify that the video after the cross-dissolve was the Zoom recording created during the first part of the video but I didn’t get that voiceover audio to come through.

Still, not bad for a first effort—and it helped the very small audience for which it was intended.

Past Tense

Posted on by Scott

We are reaching and surpassing dates in real-life that were formerly part of our science fiction. The screenshot which leads off this post is from part 1 of Past Tense, a time travel episode from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Given what the episode is about, it is even sadder that barely two months before the date in the screenshot the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that bans against sleeping outside do not violate the Eighth Amendment.

Gatekeeping Blackness is the New Birtherism

Posted on by Scott

“Kamala isn’t black” is the latest lie dividing black folks (and uniting those seeking to discredit her). I take personal offense at this particular insult as the American-born descendant of black Jamaican parents. While efforts to gatekeep black immigrants (and their descendants) out of blackness are not new, the speed with which the normally fractious and divided Democratic Party united behind Kamala Harris as their new presidential nominee after Biden dropped out has given them new fuel.

Whether they brand themselves American Descendants of Slavery (ADOS) or Foundational Black Americans (FBA), the most militant among them have decided to make common cause with Donald Trump (and his allies) and years of trafficking in xenophobic rhetoric directed against black and brown immigrants. Even the internet-infamous Curtis Scoon, who has made a career of pathologizing black folks for social media clicks had something to say that I agree with to those folks:

Curtis Scoon being right for once

A friend of mine told me that Scoon has Grenadian heritage, which probably explains the pointed nature of his rhetoric against ADOS & FBA. Speaking of Grenada, one interesting thing I learned from the limited series podcast The Empty Grave of Comrade Bishop was about Prime Minister Maurice Bishop’s speech to a predominantly black audience at Hunter College in New York City mere months before he and key members of his government were murdered and overthrown by a coup d’etat. Below is a short clip from the speech:

3 minutes, 38 seconds of Grenadian Prime Minister Maurice Bishop, speaking to an audience at Hunter College, in New York City in 1983

Political views aside, one thing that is clear from this brief clip is that Bishop’s concept of blackness was an inclusive not an exclusive one. If the raucous response of his black American audience is any indication, they were very much onboard with what he was saying. Bishop gave another speech in D.C. the same year to the Sixth Annual Dinner of TransAfrica. The full text of his remarks are quite enlightening to read this many years later. He notes the Caribbean heritage of a number distinguished black Americans–but puts their black Americanness in the forefront. A few of the names I will touch on later in this piece are all people whom ADOS/FBA would gatekeep out of blackness. To continue briefly with Grenada and its American connections, it is very important to talk about Louise Little. She is known as the mother of Malcolm X (so by the logic of ADOS/FBA he’s not black), but only when researching this piece did I learn that she was first introduced to Garveyism and the Universal Negro Improvement Association (UNIA) in Montreal by her uncle.

Garveyism is a flavor of black nationalism named for Marcus Garvey, a Jamaican immigrant to the U.S. UNIA was the black nationalist organization he founded. His separatist views were at odds with the pro-integration aims of the NAACP (and Colin Grant’s biography of Garvey suggests that he and W.E.B. DuBois hated each other), but UNIA’s presence grew enough to span 25 U.S. states (and attract the unwanted attention of J. Edgar Hoover). Garvey was inspired by Booker T. Washington, and was among the people Washington corresponded with via letters. Garvey wanted to found a school in Jamaica like Tuskegee but Washington died months before Garvey would come to the U.S. to discuss his plans. During and after his 52 years of life, his ideas would influence black nationalism, the black power movement, and Pan-Africanism, the ideas which ultimately inspired Malcolm X in similar ways to his parents. Garvey’s concept of blackness too was inclusive rather than exclusive. After Malcolm X was assassinated in 1965, Kwame Ture (previously known as Stokely Carmichael) would raise the mantle of black power. Ture hailed from Trinidad, so by ADOS/FBA logic, John Lewis’ successor as chair of SNCC was not black.

Garvey was far from the only West Indian to contribute to blackness in America in the early 20th century. Alain Locke’s 1925 anthology The New Negro, a key work heralding the Harlem Renaissance, contained numerous works by black authors from Jamaica (Claude McKay and Wilfrid A. Domingo), British Guiana (Eric Waldron), and Puerto Rico (Arturo Schomburg). Nearly one in four members of Harlem’s black residents were foreign-born in the 1920s. Looking back into the 19th century and the Civil War, we find that the black volunteers of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry regiment hailed not only from states in the Union and slave states, but from the Caribbean and Canada as well.

Contrary to the narrow and exclusive concept of blackness that ADOS/FBA advocates, black student groups protested apartheid in South Africa in the 1970s, many years before the likes of Grover Norquist, Jack Abramoff, Jeff Flake were fighting movements to boycott, divest, and sanction it (and after William F. Buckley, the intellectual father of the modern right, turned from advocating for apartheid domestically to advocating for it overseas). ADOS/FBA’s narrow and exclusive concept of blackness continues to be ignored by law enforcement in this country. Amadou Diallo (killed by plainclothes NYPD officers) was a student from Guinea. Botham Jean (murdered by his neighbor, police officer Amber Guyger) was from St. Lucia. I suspect more research would confirm that black immigrants are at just as much from police violence as black folks with solely American heritage.

Many first-generation immigrants (like my parents) have long since become citizens–and lived in the United States far longer than they ever did in their country of origin. Harry Belafonte was born in New York City, but his parents came from Jamaica. Colin Powell had both Jamaican parents and a New York City birthplace in common Belafonte. Many children of first-generation immigrants (like me) have black American wives and children. The late General Powell’s wife Alma (who passed away late last month) was originally from Alabama. My wife and in-laws hail from Columbus, Ohio, with a lineage that stretches back to Tennessee and Mississippi. Among their relatives is a now-deceased Tuskegee Airman who lived in Kansas.

Regardless of the desires and efforts of those in this country who wish to define blackness as something small and exclusive to those whose heritage is solely the United States, the history and the present of this country makes blackness a little larger. Having a heritage that includes a Caribbean island or a birthplace on the African continent does not make us any less black. Donald J. Trump and his father wouldn’t rent his apartments to us either. The anti-black racism to which too many in the United States still cling, negatively impacts every black person in this country–regardless of their heritage. Xenophobia against immigrants who look like you doesn’t improve anyone’s life.

For the better and professional version of this argument, read Adam Serwer’s piece titled What Trump’s Kamala Harris Smear Reveals.

Reaping the Whirlwind

Posted on by Scott

For they sow the wind and they reap the whirlwind. The standing grain has no heads; It yields no grain. Should it yield, strangers would swallow it up.

Hosea 8:7

The first part of this verse came to my mind rather quickly as it became clear that what happened at a Trump rally in Butler, Pennsylvania yesterday was a failed assassination attempt. It needs to be said that Trump and his allies have flooded our politics with both rhetorical and real violence for many years. Because memories and attention spans among regular citizens (and unfortunately journalists too) are quite short, it is important to push back against the continuing attempts of those on the political right to cast themselves as victims.

This ABC News piece from May 2020 catalogued no less than 54 criminal cases where those who threatened and/or perpetrated violence against people used Trump as their rationale for it, or used his name in their threats. A post I wrote 2 1/2 years ago drew connections between the January 6th insurrection and our response to the 9/11 attacks, but Trump’s speech on the Ellipse that day certainly incited the violence and deaths that would happen later. On June 16, 2015, Trump said the now-infamous, xenophobic words about who Mexico was sending. While looking for the source material for this, I came across the abstract of an undergraduate honors thesis exploring the impact of Trump’s presidency on Latinx teens which cited those same words. These examples barely even scratch the surface of how far Trump’s particularly malign influence has spread. As Trump’s legal troubles have grown (along with those of January 6th insurrectionists), threats against judges and their families have spiked to exceedingly high levels.

North Carolina lieutenant governor and gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson is one of the better and most recent examples of a politician Trump has endorsed who traffics in the same rhetorical violence he does. Robinson reportedly said the following from the pulpit of The Lake Church on June 30:

“Some folks need killing! It’s time for somebody to say it. It’s not a matter of vengeance. It’s not a matter of being mean or spiteful. It’s a matter of necessity!”

NC Newsline story by Rob Schofield, published July 5, 2024

An even more grim example of the endorsement of violence far too common among candidates and elected officials in the GOP comes from Texas governor Greg Abbott. Abbott pardoned Daniel Perry for the murder of Garrett Foster, a U.S. Air Force veteran participating in a Black Lives Matter protest against police brutality. Despite evidence that Perry planned to murder a protestor, despite a jury finding Perry guilty on the basis of that and other evidence, and despite being sentenced to 25 years for his crime, he served barely a year in prison before receiving a full pardon from the governor. The pardon will restore Perry’s right to own and use firearms. Perry is a US Army veteran who the Army removed from its ranks via a dishonorable discharge after his murder conviction.

In the years after Black Lives Matters protests spread worldwide in the wake of the murder of George Floyd by police officer Derek Chauvin, Republican legislators have sponsored and even successfully enacted into law, measures protecting drivers who injure or kill protestors with their vehicles. Jack Galle is a Louisiana Republican who recently sponsored legislation to limit the liability of drivers if they harm people illegally blocking a road or highway. Kevin Stitt, the GOP governor of Oklahoma, signed legislation in 2021 granting immunity to drivers who unintentionally injure or kill protestors. The same legislation makes penalties against demonstrators who block public roads more severe. Below is a reminder of what these GOP lawmakers are endorsing:

James Fields drivingg through a crowd of counterprotestors of the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, VA in 2017.

The picture above was taken by Ryan Kelly, who won a Pulitzer Prize for it. In 2017, a man deliberately drove his Dodge Charger into a crowd of people peacefully protesting the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, VA. He murdered Heather Heyer and injured 35 others. These are the protests of which then-President Trump said “But you also had people that were very fine people on both sides.” What precipitated the rally and the counterprotests was the proposed removal of a statue of Confederate general Robert E. Lee on horseback from a park that formerly bore his name. It was the latest in the series of removals of Confederate monuments and memorials that began in the wake of the 2015 mass shooting at the Charleston, SC church affectionately known as Mother Emanuel by yet another white supremacist.

Trump’s xenophobic rhetoric against Mexicans could certainly have been taken as encouragement by the mass shooter who murdered 22 people at a Walmart in El Paso, Texas. Beyond the recent state-endorsed anti-migrant measures of questionable legality, such as buoys on the Rio Grande with razors and razor wire strung across private property without the permission of landowners, Texas and Arizona have decades-long histories of vigilantes operating at the border between the U.S. and Mexico. Vigilantes have taken it upon themselves to impersonate government agents, to hunt, detain, and even kill migrants. Trump’s xenophobia (and that of the political far right more broadly) should also be considered in connection with his championing of birtherism conspiracy theories about Barack Obama. Trump predictably turned to the birtherism playbook again to undermine Nikki Haley’s candidacy.

The ABC News piece I linked earlier makes plain the common threads between the perpetrators of Trump-inspired violence and the victims of it this way:

The perpetrators and suspects identified in the 54 cases are mostly white men–as young as teenagers and as old as 75–while the victims largely represent an array of minority groups–African-Americans, Latinos, Muslims and gay men.

ABC News story written by Mike Levine, May 30, 2020

Both in this country’s history and in its present, the venom of violent rhetoric far more often than not infects those who go on to enact real violence against others. Black folks in particular, as well as their allies, have often been at the receiving end of political violence and terrorism. Often that violence has been aided and abetted by law enforcement, from the Reconstruction era after the Civil War, to the Orangeburg Massacre, and many lynchings, bombings, and other acts of terrorism in between. Trump has joined Alabama Governor George C. Wallace in a rare example of a political figure reaping a small measure of the violent rhetoric he has sown for many years.

In the wake of violence turning on someone who stoked such rhetoric for years, we are predictably hearing calls to turn down heated rhetoric from anti-woke publications like The Free Press, from House speaker Mike Johnson (who could be found earlier this spring spreading disinformation re: students protesting the war in Gaza and arguably inciting violence against protestors), and others in the GOP. When it comes to the political right however, we are talking about the same group of people responsible for what you see below:

Democratic elected officials condemning the violence and wishing Trump a full recovery were easy to find, including President Biden, former president Obama, and former House speaker Nancy Pelosi.

Former speaker Pelosi’s husband Paul was attacked by a man with a hammer by a believer in the QAnon conspiracy theory (which Trump has embraced and amplified for years). It is very easy to find video of Trump telling jokes about Paul Pelosi being assaulted, and his audience laughing along with him.

Others can and will draw false equivalences between political violence from the ideological left and right. I won’t waste time doing that. The political registration of the would-be assassin (Republican) and his $15 financial donation (Democrat) are far less relevant than his easy access to a dangerous weapon (courtesy of his father) and reports that he was bullied as a child. We have seen incels with guns engage in mass shootings before, with women as their primary victims. It should be noted that both the increasingly broad availability guns, and in the places they can be carried, and in laws that reduce or eliminate the liability of those who shoot and kill others if they claim self-defense are largely championed by the GOP.

Not only is the predominant source of the threat of political violence and terrorism abundantly clear, that has been the case for years. The GOP has actively opposed efforts to give the federal government tools to combat domestic terrorism going back to the immediate aftermath of the Oklahoma City bombing. The GOP destroyed the careers of those in the DHS who warned of an increase in right-wing extremism in the wake of the election of Barack Obama. The GOP’s deliberate destruction of the federal government’s ability to provide intelligence and act as a resource for local law enforcement led directly to Charlottesville PD having no federal support with which to counter the white supremacist and neo-Nazi elements that descended on their city in 2017, and to the Oath Keepers being able to grow unchecked into a group whose members would man a stack formation which would ultimately breach the Capitol during the January 6th insurrection.

It should go without saying that political violence is bad for the United States. Even a small country like Jamaica has been beset by political violence for decades. Political violence ought to be condemned, and I add my small voice to the chorus who condemn it today in good faith. But we ought not accept unchallenged such calls to turn down heated rhetoric from the very same people who turned the rhetorical temperature up in the first place. We can and should condemn political violence at the same time we call out hypocrisy.